A bigger ozone hole isn't a verdict on the Montreal Protocol
The Antarctic hole is the largest in a decade, but a strong polar vortex, not policy failure, explains it. Recovery is slow and noisy, and one season is not a trend.
Photo: NOAASatellites / Wikimedia Commons (Public domain)
Is the ozone layer failing to heal, or are we just bad at reading a noisy chart? The headline of the week, that the Antarctic ozone hole has grown to a size not seen in a decade, invites the first reading. The data supports the second.
Here is what happened. According to ScienceDaily's report on the NASA and NOAA findings, the 2026 hole peaked on September 18 at 10.5 million square miles (27.1 million square kilometers), about 90% of the largest ever measured, in 2000. Averaged over September 7 to October 13, it covered roughly 9.6 million square miles (25 million square kilometers). Yet by average seasonal area it ranks only seventh-largest in 48 years of observations.
That last detail matters, and the headlines tend to bury it. "Biggest in a decade" and "seventh-largest on record" describe the same season. The first sounds like a reversal, while the second sounds like a bad year in a long, uneven series.
The culprit was the weather, not the chemistry
The mechanism is not mysterious. The scientists attribute the expansion mainly to an exceptionally strong polar vortex, the band of winds that circles Antarctica and traps very cold air. That cold air allows the stratospheric clouds on which chlorine and bromine do their damage. NOAA's Amy Butler explained that the planetary-scale weather systems that usually break up the vortex were especially weak in August and September. The result was a bigger area where conditions favored ozone loss.
In other words, the ingredients were the same as ever and the weather changed how much of the polar stratosphere they could reach. Nothing in the scientists' explanation points to new ozone-destroying emissions. We think that is the key distinction: the size of the hole in a single year is partly a meteorological variable, and a meteorological variable should not be read as a verdict on a treaty.
The Montreal Protocol is visible in the details
The more interesting numbers are the ones that did not break records. Ozone directly above the South Pole bottomed out at 105 Dobson units on October 17, while the lowest ever measured was 92, in October 2006. Scientists also noted that this year did not see the same extreme ozone loss as the record events of 10 or 20 years ago. Large but shallow is a very different animal from large and deep.
Then there is the counterfactual. Paul Newman, who has long led NASA's ozone research team at Goddard, said the hole could have been larger if ozone-depleting substances were as prevalent today as at their year 2000 peak. He also noted that the annual hole has been forming later in the season in recent years, which he reads as a sign the layer is healing. Counterfactuals are the hardest thing to sell to the public, because nobody celebrates the disaster that didn't happen. But this is exactly what a working treaty looks like: a bad year that is less bad than it would have been.
What to take from it
There are two ways to get this wrong. One is alarm: treating a single big season as proof that the 1987 agreement has failed. The other is complacency: assuming healing means every year will be better than the last. The agencies' own framing sits between the two. The layer is recovering and remains on track to heal later this century, but "later this century" is a long runway, and along it the vortex will keep delivering good and bad years.
Our recommendation is simple. Judge the ozone layer by multi-year trends, the timing of the hole's formation and the depth of the loss, not by whichever year gets the "biggest since" label. And if you want a public lesson from this season, it is that environmental diplomacy can work and still look unimpressive on a single chart. The Montreal Protocol doesn't need this year to be a good one. It needs us to keep watching the decades.
No topics yet: start the first one.
More stories
The "monster" El Niño headline is the least useful part of this story
Comparing 2026 to 1997 helps governments prepare, but it is a poor forecast, and the real value lies in the monitoring that tells us months ahead what is coming.
The desert's hidden carbon cycle is a measuring problem, not a rescue
A mineral carbon cycle in the Mojave suggests our carbon books may be missing parts of the arid world, a reason to measure drylands properly, not to hope they bail us out.
Tectonics built Asia's rainforests, but it wasn't alone
Australia's slow crash into Asia helped fill Southeast Asia's forests with species, but new amber fossils suggest the story starts much earlier and is messier than a collision.
Bird droppings may be the cheapest sea wall tropical islands have
A new Science Advances study suggests seabird guano feeds reefs that keep atolls growing. Protecting the birds looks like smart coastal defense, but it can't stop the sea by itself.



